Tuesday, April 14, 2020

April 14 - COVID-19 in Westchester County, NY

Here are the updated charts with data through April 13, 2020. Click on a chart to enlarge it.

Hospitalizations at the state level and in NYC continue to go down.  Unfortunately, Westchester does not publish their hospitalization rate. The history for NYC is shown below.

NYC Hospitalizations



Deaths in Westchester went down for the second day in a row (orange line). That is not enough data to declare that it is a trend.



New cases for NYC, Westchester, and Nassau all declined, but there was also reduced testing. Was that a result of the Easter weekend or a real change in the requests for tests?  The percent of results coming back postive is still over 40%, indicating that tests are still being rationed.




Bergamo, Italy is still struggling to get their new cases below 100.  They first dropped below 100 a week ago, but continue to hover at that rate. I could not find the death rate for that province, but the death rate in Italy overall is dropping. The blue curve is the best fit of the Westchester data to a gaussian distribution.  The orange curve fits the early Westchester data, but uses a duration similar to the duration of the epidemic in Bergamo.





Monday, April 13, 2020

April 13 - COVID-19 in Westchester County, NY

Here are the updated charts with data through April 12, 2020. Click on a chart to enlarge it.

There is something strange going on with the viral spread in the NYC metro area.  Hospitalizations and intubations are going down (see chart below), which means the death rates should be going down soon, but they have not yet (see Orange Line in Westchester chart). However, the rate of new cases has not gone down in greater NYC (includes Westchester and Nassau). Are all of these new cases minor symptoms with no hospitalization required? Has this been seen in other countries?




The new cases in NYC, Nassau, and Westchester are still stuck on a plateau and are at about the same rate per capita.  Test results are over 40% positive. This is much higher than other parts of NYS or the rest of the country.



The table below shows testing per capita for different counties in NYS. Westchester leads the list with over 5% of the population tested. (About 2% are confirmed infected).  Manhattan does not make the top 10. Westchester was the location of the first case in NYS so that may explain part of it. It is also the weathiest county in the state, so the county labs may have been better prepared? Despite the high load of infections, there have been few reports of chaos in Westchester hospitals.

Number of tests per 100,000 residents


Westchester also makes the top ten in deaths per capita. (The data is a few days old.  Westchester is now up to 50 deaths per 100,000.)

Number of deaths per 100,000 residents


There is little change in the comparison curves for New Cases between Westchester and its sister province of Bergamo, Italy.



The Swedish Model
A few days ago, I recommended a scenario for getting back to normal.  I recently found out that this is close to the strategy pursued by the Swedes (their approach is a bit more lackadaisical than I suggested). It is lauded by some, but deplored by others. In my view it is a great control group for the massive social and economic destruction going elsewhere in the developed world. To take that a bit further, I would like to see states follow different models of "reopening." This would generate more data on what might be the best response to future pandemics. For 'experts' to say that they know the best course of action is preposterous when so little is understood about this virus and how to minimize its long term effects on our world.

Sunday, April 12, 2020

April 12 - COVID-19 in Westchester County, NY

Here are the updated charts with data through April 11, 2020. Click on a chart to enlarge it.

This is Day 19 of this blog topic. The New Cases in Westchester had already 'peaked' 19 days-ago. Since then, it appears that Westchester has just been sitting on that peak. Today's plot of new cases includes a curve that has the same 'duration' as the Bergamo Italy New Case curve. This curve (orange line) predicts that if the Westchester epidemic has the same duration as the Bergamo epidemic, it will be April 27 before the New Case Count drops below 100 per day.



The New Death Count for Westchester jumped to 72 for a total of 461 deaths. (The County death reporting has been delayed in the past. It was obtained through local newspapers who received it from County officials. The State is now reporting county by county deaths on a daily basis.)  This increases the Westchester death rate to 2.5% of confirmed cases (461/18729).



The New Cases reported by NYC, Westchester, and Nassau were all about the same on a per capita basis.



The influenza-like illness detected by Kinsa continues to drop to unexpected levels for Westchester, but still exceeds the level for the USA overall.



Clinical Studies
There is an unprecedented effort to come up with therapies for COVID-19. Several Life Sciences companies have formed a consortium to coordinate searches for therapies. The FDA already lists about 200 clinical studies that have been submitted. It seems encouraging until one reads the "expected completion dates." They are all well into the future. 

Saturday, April 11, 2020

April 11 - COVID-19 in Westchester County, NY

Here are the updated charts with data through April 10, 2020. Click on a chart to enlarge it.

Yesterday, New York reported the first negative change in ICU beds.  More beds were being emptied than were being filled with new patients.




This conflicts with the increase in New Cases seen in most jurisditions.  I have found no explanation for this in any of the state or city press releases.  Because noone has raised a flag, I assume this is just a backlog of test results coming in. In fact, the city has started counting New Cases by the Day on which the swab was taken.  Their new curve is seen below along with my chart which is plotted by the Day of Test Result.





For a change, I have plotted the Westchester data on a log scale.  The epidemiologists like this because it is easier to see the bending of the curve.



There is not much change in the comparison plot with Westchester's "sister county," Bergamo, Italy.



Opinion
My trust in Dr. Fauci sank again yesterday during a discussion about relaxing stay-at-home orders for low-risk persons. Apparently a governor had stated that noone under 25 had died. Dr. Fauci stood up and stated that that was incorrect. There have been deaths of persons under 25.
While it is true that persons under 25 have died, if he is really a person driven by data, he would admit it is a very small number.  Here are the numbers from New York which are a majority of the deaths in the USA.



Deaths of persons under 20 is 0.1%!!  Under 30-years-of-age is 0.6%!!  I think that rounds to zero!!

And then he states that the "social distancing is working."  And while I agree, why has he been lecturing me about "correlation is not causation" for the past two weeks? Where is his randomized controlled study to prove the cause of reduced infections really is the social distancing measures? Ohhhhh, because those are HIS experiments!!??!! Beware of those who make rules for thee but not for me!

Friday, April 10, 2020

April 10 - COVID-19 in Westchester County, NY

Here are the updated charts with data through April 9, 2020. Click on a chart to enlarge it.

There is still an anomaly in the reporting of New Cases for Westchester, Nassau, and NYC (catching up with a backlog of tests?).  That data conflicts with the New Hospitalization data that is clearly going down. The hospitalization data for NYC is shown below.  The data for the state is similar. There are about 1000 hospitalized in Westchester which is 6% of the cases or 0.1% of the population.



The deaths reported in Westchester increased to 359 which is 2.1% of the confirmed cases or about 3.5 per 10,000 residents.



The recent anomalous high number of tests and resulting number of positives is making the epidemic curve stretch out.  It is starting to look more like Bergamo, Italy (a similary-sized province that was hit early and hard as was Westchester) in duration.



Nassau and NYC have also seen the recent anomalous influx of test results.



The IMHE model for deaths in NYS has not been updated since yesterday, so it is not shown.

======================
Therapies
The White House task force said there are 19? therapies in active clinical trials and another 29 in the planning stages. My old employer, Pfizer, just dug an old protease inhibitor out of their historical anti-viral portfolio and found it has in-vitro activity against SARS-CoV-2.  Hmmm.   Dr. Raoult will be releasing his observational study of over 1000 patients in France using the hydroxycholroquine-azithromycin combo.  The summary table has already been released.

Travel
My brother sent me this graphic of daily air travel decline.




The decline in travel by train is similar. About 30% of  Westchester households use commuter trains to work in NYC. That ridership is now at 2% of normal.

Personal
I still know noone in Westchester who has been tested (positive or negative). That is hard to believe as over 5% of the county has been tested. I may recognize the face of the Trader Joe's worker who died, but I did not really know that person.

I volunteer at a historical society on the other side of the Hudson River in Orange County. The virus is just starting to sweep that county.  Last night, the president of the society, who I know well, told me her 74-year-old brother and his 50-year-old son died of the corona virus in Warwick, Orange County. I had met her brother several times. Very sad times.

Thursday, April 9, 2020

April 9 - COVID-19 in Westchester County, NY

Here are the updated charts with data through April 8, 2020. Click on a chart to enlarge it.

Today's death count for New York State is predicted to be the maximum. (Technically, this is the count that will be reported tomorrow, so it would not appear in my blog until 2 days from now). I believe the death count max for Westchester should have been a few days ago.  Source IHME.




There was an anomaly in the New Cases reported yesterday. No flags were raised in the NYS Briefing, so it appears to be the nature of the reporting and not a true indication that cases have jumped.  My guess is that a laboratory released all of its test results for the last several days in one big dump. The number of tests in all entities almost doubled, so naturally so did the 'positives.' 







The Kinsa ILI map continues to show very low incidence of illness in Westchester.. In fact, all of the above the data seem to suggest that the spread of corona virus has been under control for some weeks.




Getting back to normal
You will hear many opinions in the next few weeks about how and when to reopen the economy (if you haven't already).  It would be nice to have more data, but the patient (the economy) can't wait. This blog is usually about the facts, but here is my take on what we can do once the hospitalization utilization drops to normal in a particular region.  This can all be adjusted as we get more data about the degree of immunity in various populations.

1. People who carry the antibodies should return to normal life.

2. If you are under 45 with no underlying conditions, you may go back to work now.  If you get flu symptoms, go home!  Your risks of getting hospitalized froom COVID are small. Even if you get the virus, the hospitals will not be stressed.  Continue to maintain social distancing and work from home if possible. Beware that you or other family members could be bringing the virus into your home, so maintain good hygiene and social distancing in the home until you can all get antibody testing.

3. If you are 65+, continue to stay-at-home. You are the highest risk group and now that others are out and about, you need to take care of yourself.  Do not gather with family or other groups. For this country to step towards normalcy, you must sacrifice a bit longer or the whole thing will blow up. You must be even MORE careful now than in the last period!

4. School-age kids should return to normal activities. Learn! After all we need a smarter group than our current leaders of science, government, and media who had less than a stellar performance on this one. You will get sick and not even know it, but soon you and your playmates will develop herd immunity.  Unfortunately, because you will be carriers, you must stay away from the elderly. In fact, you are sort of like a banished group for a while. Stay out of stores, restaurants, or any place with groups of adults.

5. If you are 45-64, get an antibody test. After health-care workers and first responders, this should be the group targeted for the antibody test.  If you test positive, you have immunity.  Return to work as #1. If you are negative and have no underlying conditions, you are at low risk and can resume work (as #2) where minimal close interpersonal contact is possible. If you are negative and have underlying conditions, behave as #3 above.

6. All of these measures can be done when hospitalization utilization returns to normal, but it is also possible to phase in #1 then #2...  Remember, it takes two or three weeks from infection to hospital admission, so the effect of implementing any of these will not be apparent for several weeks, maybe a month.  We still don't understand exactly how the disease is transmitted, so we should still maintain the social distance measures and face masks.  Assume every school-age kid is a carrier. To live with this we should not allow them in stores and restaurants where they could infect others. But let them live with each other in ballgames, playgrounds, etc. Herd immunity will soon protect this age group with little risk to them....only to those around them. That is the trade off...let them live, but segregate them.

All of this can be modified as we learn more about the geographical spread, more about transmision, more about therapies, and do more antibody testing. But much of this we can start soon in areas where hospital utilization is near normal.  JUST AN OPINION based on hospital and death demographics.

Wednesday, April 8, 2020

April 8 - COVID-19 in Westchester County, NY

Here are the updated charts with data through April 7, 2020. Click on a chart to enlarge it.

New cases in Westchester County, NY have declined for the 5th straight day. Despite having one of the highest per capita infection rates in the country (about 1.5% confirmed infected vs NYC at less than 1%) only about 10% are being hospitalized.  The county hospitals have been able to handle that load which is currently about 10,000 patients.


Ideally we should track New Infections. New Infections lead to New Symptoms (2-14d) -> New Tests (1-14d) -> New Cases (0-4d) -> New Hospitalizations -> New Deaths. Unfortunately, the most accurate statistic is the New Deaths, which is a very late indicator of the status of the virus in the population.  The earliest indicator we can measure is New Cases (that is why I show that statistic most frequently). But the time between the the actual virus transmission and obtaining the test result (which is the definition of New Case) is 3 to 32 days. The New Case Count peaked on about March 30, or about 14 days after the stay-at-home order. If the New Cases follow the gaussian curve, we should hit less than 10 per day by April 17. But if the curve is really as broad as the Bergamo curve, it could be May 1 before we reach that level.





The peak in NY State deaths is predicted for 2 days from today. I cannot compare that with Westchester deaths as the public reporting is delayed. Because Westchester is a few days further down the curve than NYC and a few more days in front of the rest of the state, deaths have probably already peaked in Westchester.



The kinsa health map says that the entire nation has an unusually low level of influenza-like illness...about 1%.  That is what social distancing does. What if we find out that we saved 10,000 influenza deaths this year in addition to slowing the corona virus? Will we finally admit that living has its risks? Will we choose to live? Or will we recede into our caves until anarchy brings us to our senses?




Even in Westchester we are sliding into a range of less influenza-like illness than expected.




Trader Joe's
I am lucky that I have not been inconvenienced much by the stay-at-home orders.  I am largely a recluse, training in my home gym, cooking my GF meals, reading. But I had complained publicly about not being able to shop at my favorite grocery store, Trader Joe's, for over a month due to the crowds. TJ stores have small footprints and sell three-times as much grocery per square foot than the typical Kroger or Publix. There is no backroom or off-hours shelf stocking.  The workers are always on the floor and visible.

Sadly, a clerk at my TJ's just died from COVID-19. The store is closed until Thursday.  I am sure I knew this person. I extend my deepest thanks to all food-supply workers who have sustained us through this ordeal.